Web Toastie


Social Media and SEO Blog of a Search Marketing Consultant

17 Dec, 2009

Rel=“nofollow” Exploitations?

You are here: Home » SEO » Rel=“nofollow” Exploitations?

I came across an interesting thread on the Google Webmaster Help Forums today regarding potential nofollow exploitations. The question asked was whether a rel=”follow” attribute added to a HTML link would void the nofollow that is in place. Adding rel=”follow” of course does nothing on it’s own, but having two rel= attributes seems to cause Google to interpret the link differently.

The example the user posted was:

<a rel="follow" href="http://www.example.com/" rel="nofollow">Example</a>

Matt Cutts replied to the question with the following:

Good question. I’ve seen 1-2 other people wondering about this. The short answer is that we’ll make sure the rel=”nofollow” takes precedence. Otherwise spammers could exploit this.

His response implies that the issue could cause problems, but he didn’t say exactly when Google would eradicate the problem.

This potential exploit could allow spammers to use forums and blogs (where links tend to be nofollowed) to gain more valuable links back to their own websites. Until Google fixes the problem that is – which would be pretty soon I would imagine.

No related posts.

Enjoyed this post? Enter your email address here to receive updates whenever a new article is published on Web Toastie:

Delivered by FeedBurner

8 Responses to "Rel=“nofollow” Exploitations?"

1 | Brad

December 22nd, 2009 at 12:11 pm

Avatar

Hmm I think the no follow would over ride the do follow…but who knows.

2 | Jonathon

December 29th, 2009 at 5:51 pm

Avatar

Why would “follow” even be noticed by Google? by default links are already “follow” so only “nofollow” would override that and if you put “follow” (assuming Google understood that tag) wouldn’t the corresponding “nofollow” tag override that too?

3 | marcus

December 29th, 2009 at 6:42 pm

Avatar

My understanding of what Matt stated that adding the dofollow tag would not work because the no follow would take precedence. In other words…you will not gain a backlink using this tactic.

4 | Kieron Hughes

December 29th, 2009 at 10:19 pm

Avatar

@Jonathon – The point being made is that the nofollow attribute recognised by Google would be overridden by adding a second ‘rel=’ tag into the link. Presumably the nofollow tag will take precedence, but Matt Cutts implied that it could be open to exploitations. I’m sure it will have been fixed by now though.

@marcus – I think Matt implied that it could be potentially exploited (as I’ve just mentioned), but the likelihood of that happening seems very slim – especially now.

5 | idgnarn

December 30th, 2009 at 10:52 am

Avatar

I think nofollow will over ride the follow, but there is no idea why google interpret it differently.

6 | joyce

December 31st, 2009 at 5:30 am

Avatar

ya i also think rel=”nofollow” takes precedence. Otherwise spammers could exploit.spammers to use forums and blogs where links tend to be nofollowed is used to get more back links to website.

7 | John Wood

March 3rd, 2010 at 2:50 pm

Avatar

All interesting, but would Google for instance note the content in the link?

e.g.

If a network site generates text such as “Widgets, gizmos and thingamabobs” would there be a boost to the site ‘mysite’ for those keywords even though pagerank would not be affected.

Since Google tends to uplift sites when lots of people are talking about them on networking sites the anewer would seem to be ‘yes’

8 | John Wood

March 3rd, 2010 at 2:53 pm

Avatar

Drat! did not expect forum to convert code into a link!

‘mysite.com’ rel=”nofollow”> Widgets, gizmos and thingamabobs

Comment Form


About

Web Toasite is the social media and SEO blog of Kieron Hughes - a Manchester search marketing consultant with experience running SEO campaigns in a variety of sectors online.

Kieron blogs about SEO industry news, web development and advances in social media. If you wish to contact Kieron you can do so through the online contact form, or connect via the following social networking websites.